Department Of The Lunar New Year
Happy Year of the Fire Horse, to my SIL and to all who celebrate the Lunar New Year (aka Chinese New Year). [1]
* * *
Department Of Things You’re Not Supposed To Say Or Even Think About When Watching A Supposedly Inspiring Documentary;
Specifically, Netflix’s Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart
Sub-Department Of, Why Isn’t She Pissed Off?
And by “pissed off” moiself means filled with white-hot rage, the throwing-chairs-out-of-the-windows-of-a-high-rise-building kind of fury.
The Elizabeth Smart documentary came recommended for me on my Netflix feed last week, and I started watching it one morning as I did my elliptical workout. It took me several days to get through it; I could only take 15 m or so at a time. As the days went by, moiself got more and more angry. Angry as in, Why Did I Watch This Shit®? Not that the subject of the documentary was shit; I refer to the integral bullshit contained within the story – the bullshit of religion and religious theology lurking behind the tragedy, the bullshit that is and was, IMO, responsible for it.

Look up the story if you have been living under a rock are one of the few American adults who does not know it. The basics: Elizabeth Smart was fourteen years old, one of six children in a prosperous and respected Mormon family, when she was kidnapped from her family’s Salt Lake City home. Her abductors, a self-described religious prophet and his wife, [2] held Smart captive for nine months. Smart was sexually assaulted by “the prophet,” and subjected to emotional assaults and physical deprivations by her abductors. She endured nine months of this until she was rescued by police (after receiving a citizen’s tip) when she and her captors were walking down a street in Sandy, Utah.
At one point in the documentary, after Smart was rescued and returned to her family, there is footage of Smart being referred to as “… the most prayed-for person in America.” And that just wrenched my stomach. I had to turn the documentary off at that point, and returned to it another day.
“… the most prayed for person in America.” Fat lotta good those hyper-abundant prayers did. I’m sure Smart herself was the most prayer-ful person in American during her captivity, praying at least fifty bajillion times a day to be delivered from her anguish, each and every time “the prophet” was assaulting her.
People who engage in intercessory prayer seem to do so with the assumptions that (a) their god is listening to them, and (b) their god is capable of acting in our world. And yet it took their god nine months to get off his holy ass, while a 14-year-old girl was daily – daily – raped by an adult man. Prayers didn’t stop that. [3]
BTW: Questions were raised, both in the documentary and in news articles at the time of Smart’s release, about the adult woman (the wife of the “prophet”) complicit in Smart’s kidnapping and abuse. And I’m thinking, Really? You find this surprising? The woman was the product of abuse herself – she was a captive within a paranoid, patriarchal religious mindset, where the man is in charge and his word and will ultimately prevails…. Yeah, there’s always the question of one’s own internal sense of right or wrong. But what happened to that woman, and to Elizabeth Smart, was not a *perversion * of conservative, patriarchal religion, but a sadly logical (if appalling) part of the spectrum.
Of all the frustratingly heartbreaking situations detailed in the documentary, the “near” rescue got to me the most. This happened when Smart’s abductors had taken her into a small town [4] with them when they needed to purchase supplies. Smart and the prophet’s wife were always shrouded in Burqa-like garments the few times they were in public, and on this outing, the three of them were stopped and questioned on the street – by a police officer looking for Smart (! ). The “prophet” abductor answered the officer’s questions about why he refused to let Smart show her face by telling the officer that the girl was his daughter, and that their religion decreed that his daughter must not show her face to any man save for her father and her future husband.
!! The officer accepted that answer, and left without questioning Smart !!
Smart’s captor’s excuse answer was accepted because he phrased it in terms of “our religion says…” And in Utah, it’s likely that religious excuses are allowed even more privilege (read: religion is allowed to excuse a multitude of “sins” and abuses) than in society as a whole, given the state’s history as a Mormon stronghold and the Mormon religion’s history of polygamy and patriarchy.
Although Smart was eventually freed from almost a year of horrific fear and abuse, I would argue that the cognitive abuse still lingers. I don’t think Smart has left either her religion in specific or religion in general; thus, IMO, she continues to participate in the system that ultimately spawned and tolerated her abuse in the first place.
I was reminded of a quote by Butterfly McQueen, the actor and civil rights and Freethought activist. I wish Smart a similar epiphany.
Back to the praying for Elizabeth Smart thing. I recall reading news stories, after Smart was found, reporting that thanks were being “….given to God” by people around the country. This god was being credited for Smart finally being found. Now, if you attribute agency to the deity for somehow enabling Smart to be found, you should also acknowledge that that same god set aside its agency to act – that same god sat on its pedophile-observing ass for nine months – while a fourteen-year-old-girl was being tormented, and while her family endured the torment of not knowing where their child was nor what she was going through.
If Smart’s abduction happened today our social media pages would be filled with requests to “pray for Elizabeth and her family.” Meanwhile, we Freethinkers, atheists, skeptics, and other rational, religion-free folk metaphorically bang our foreheads against the walls of ignorance and superstition as we ponder why, for nine months after Smart was abducted, so many people pled for assistance from their omnipresent, omniscient, omnipotent, every-caring/ever loving deity who was either absent or stood by (translation: who did *nothing*) when he was truly needed – when a child was being dragged from her bedroom, her atttacker holding a knife to her neck, at 2 am. [5]
Years later, as an adult, Smart became an advocate for survivors of sexual violence. I kept waiting for the mention of her advocacy work – there was just a sliver of it at the end of the documentary. Moiself was not surprised by this; still, I was infuriatingly disappointed that there was not even a cursory forensic analysis, or mention, of why Smart needed to do such advocacy work in the first place. [6]
I was disappointed that Smart’s feelings of guilt and shame, and of being “dirty” due to being raped, were only briefly mentioned in the documentary, and that there was little mention of either the specific or general cultural influences of Smart’s – of any person’s – patriarchal conservative religion that is related to – or as moiself would put it, directly responsible for – Smart having those feelings. IMO, almost as sickening as Smart’s abduction/rape is the culture of religiously ordained male dominance which allows such acts to occur in the first place.
Years after her rescue, [7] Smart has critiqued the purity culture she was raised in, and which surrounds girls in conservative/evangelical religious families. This culture implies (read: overtly teaches) that a woman’s/girl’s ultimate worth is not what’s in her heart and head, but between her legs.
“In 2014, during a poignant and emotional speech at Johns Hopkins University, Elizabeth Smart revealed she had received this abstinence-only sex education lesson prior to her being kidnapped from her room as a child. While in captivity, she was then repeatedly raped by her captor. And that lesson – that teacher who told her that she would be a worthless, old piece of gum if she engaged in premarital sex – not only stayed with her, but it also made her wonder whether there was any point in trying to escape.
‘For me, I thought, ‘Oh my gosh. I’m that chewed up piece of gum,’ Smart told the audience of gathered listeners. ‘Nobody re-chews a piece of gum. You throw it away. And that’s how easy it is to feel like you no longer have worth, you no longer have value. Why would it even be worth screaming out? Why would it even make a difference if you are rescued, if your life still has no value?’ ” [8]
” Even though male students are encouraged to take these (purity) pledges too, the lessons often focus on young women. For example, a way in which purity pledges are done is where gold rose pins are handed out at Christian youth group events, with a small card attached that says: ‘You are like a beautiful rose. Each time you engage in premarital sex, a precious petal is stripped away. Don’t leave your future husband holding a bare stem. Abstain.’ ”
(excerpt, “The Negative Implications of the Purity Movement on Young Women.” The Review: A Journal of Undergraduate Student Research 15 (2014): 9-18. Paul, Amanda )
-” ‘ If you have premarital sex you become a ‘chewed up piece of gum.’ ”
Anyone else hear this rhetoric growing up? As a guy I even remember hearing this shit. My poor wife has so much emotional baggage to work through because of the whole impurity bullshit.”
-“Yeah. Just imagine being gang raped as a little girl and then hearing this. And yes, I was dumped by someone who couldn’t stand ‘thinking about the men who already used me’ when he found out about my childhood.” [9]
– “I got the ‘chewed up piece of gum,’ ‘duct tape that loses its stickiness,’ and was told that as a woman, I start with a jar of M&Ms. Every person I have sex with gets some of my M&Ms. If I’m not careful, I’ll run out of M&Ms and have none left to give my future husband.
I think the one that disgusts me the most is when people talk about women dressing ‘provocatively’ and being assaulted, and make the statement ‘well you wouldn’t expect a dog to stay away from a raw piece of steak.’ So…Women are objects and men are animals. Thanks.”
( excerpts, social media threads on ex-Christians and their experiences
with the purity movement )
“Where does a woman’s value lie? In her brain? Her heart? Her spirit?
According to right-wing culture warriors, ‘between her legs.’ That’s what underlies the emphasis on virginity as ‘purity,’ and the push for abstinence-only education. And it has very real consequences, most recently articulated by Elizabeth Smart.
Smart, who was kidnapped and held for months while her captor repeatedly raped her, recently discussed how her religious background made her feel worthless after the first rape – how she understands why others wouldn’t even try to escape, if, like her, they were taught that a sexually ‘impure’ woman had nothing to offer.
“I think it goes even beyond fear, for so many children, especially in sex trafficking. It’s feelings of self-worth. It’s feeling like, ‘Who would ever want me now? I’m worthless.’
That is what it was for me the first time I was raped. I was raised in a very religious household, one that taught that sex was something special that only happened between a husband and a wife who loved each other. And that’s how I’d been raised, that’s what I’d always been determined to follow: that when I got married, then and only then would I engage in sex.
After that first rape, I felt crushed. Who could want me now? I felt so dirty and so filthy. I understand so easily all too well why someone wouldn’t run because of that alone.”
( excerpts, “‘Purity’ culture: bad for women, worse for survivors of sexual assault,”
The Guardian, May 2014, by Jill Filipovic )
* * *
Department Of Quote Of The Week
“I saw a guy walking down the street, wearing a football jersey.
So I tackled him, because he was asking for it.”
( Anonymous )
* * *
Freethinkers’ Thought Of The Week [10]
“I’m an atheist, and Christianity appears to me to be the most absurd imposture of all the religions, and I’m puzzled that so many people can’t see through a religion that encourages irresponsibility and bigotry.”
( Butterfly McQueen, quoted in Warren Allen Smith’s
Celebrities in Hell. Barricade Books. p. 75. )
* * *
May you have a favorite Celebrity in Hell;
May your life’s worth never be compared to a piece of chewing gum;
May you fight the good fight against patriarchal religion everything;
…and may the hijinks ensue.
Thanks for stopping by. Au Vendredi!
* * *
[1] Except, of course, there are many more countries/cultures that also celebrate the Lunar New Year, primarily but not exclusively Southeast Asian, including Korea, Vietnam, Singapore, Thailand, Malaysia….
[2] Whose names are not worthy of taking up column space in this blog.
[3] Perhaps they weren’t specific enough.
[4] They moved frequently, but mostly stayed in an encampment not far from where Smart was abducted.
[5] Exact time unknown; generally referred to as “in the early morning.”
[6] Well, duh/of course not. This documentary was made with her cooperation, and it needed/wanted a “feel good” ending.
[7] E.g., in speeches during her sexual assault survivors advocacy work.
[8] Exact Reference lost…there were so many, from stories of her speeches…
[9] The poster had been sexually abused.
[10] “free-think-er n. A person who forms opinions about religion on the basis of reason, independently of tradition, authority, or established belief. Freethinkers include atheists, agnostics and rationalists. No one can be a freethinker who demands conformity to a bible, creed, or messiah. To the freethinker, revelation and faith are invalid, and orthodoxy is no guarantee of truth.” Definition courtesy of the Freedom From Religion Foundation, ffrf.org